Chicago pizza is not one thing. The deep-dish gets the tourist press, but the city runs on tavern-cut thin crust, cracker-crisp and cut in squares, the kind that goes with a beer and a Bears game. These 16 spots cover both traditions, plus a few rooms that earn their place for other reasons.
Compare all 16 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
The pizza pot pie is the order here, a domed, inverted individual pie that takes a full thirty minutes and arrives unlike anything else on the North Side. The combo grinder and the shareable meditation bread round out a menu built for a long, unhurried table. Walk-in waits run about an hour even off-peak, and the room holds the whole party before seating, so plan accordingly.
2121 N Clark St, Chicago, IL 60614 · (773) 248-2570
Paradise Park runs tavern pizza out of a large, booth-heavy room with bar seating and enough space to absorb a full Friday crowd. The specialty and appetizer pizzas draw repeat visits, and the format suits group nights well. Reservations are worth making for anything after five on a weekend; the place fills fast and the scale of the room rewards showing up with a full table.
1913 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60622 · (773) 687-9117
Pizzeria Uno is where the deep-dish story starts, a 1940s Chicago invention that became the tourist icon. The Uno Pizza, loaded with pepperoni, sausage, onions, green peppers, and extra cheese, is the standard order. The food takes close to forty-five minutes, which is the nature of the format. Locals eat tavern-cut far more often, but if deep-dish is on the itinerary, this is the original room.
Piece makes New Haven-style pizza in Wicker Park, a thin-crust format that sits apart from both the deep-dish and the local tavern tradition. The pies run massive, and the house-brewed beer list gives the room a brewpub character that suits long group meals. Two large pies and a large salad handled five people with room to spare. A solid detour if the Connecticut-style cracker-thin is what the table is after.
1927 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60622 · (773) 772-4422
Exchequer sits in a historic building near the Loop with mafia-themed wall decor and a bar crowd that treats the place as a regular stop. The baked goat cheese and meatballs are strong enough openers that the pizza sometimes gets skipped entirely. The room has a lived-in character that separates it from the newer downtown spots, and the bartenders get named in the record with enough regularity to mean something.
226 S Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60604 · (312) 939-5633
Pizzeria Due is the companion room to Uno, a few blocks away, running the same deep-dish tradition with attentive service and a forty-minute wait on the pie. The Italian chopped salad and thin crust are also on the menu for those who want a shorter ticket time. Due draws a mix of regulars and first-timers; the staff reputation holds up across the record as the room's consistent strength.
619 N Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60611, United States · (312) 943-2400
Bonci operates as a by-the-slice room where the format lets a table sample several varieties in one sitting. The crispy onion pizza and spicy eggplant are the standouts; the vegan options have their own following. Slices are sold by weight, cut to order from large rectangular trays, which is the Roman al taglio approach. For a quick midday stop or a casual group lunch, the format works.
161 N Sangamon St, Chicago, IL 60607, United States · (312) 243-4016
Jimmy's Pizza Cafe runs New York-style slices at a price point that keeps it squarely in everyday-lunch territory. The margherita holds up as the best slice in the case; the white pizza and garlic knots round out an order for two. The room is kid-friendly and low-key, and the ticket size at the one-dollar price tier makes it a practical neighborhood stop on the North Side.
2434 W Montrose Ave, Chicago, IL 60618 · (773) 293-6992
The Art of Pizza offers both deep-dish and thin-crust at a counter-service price point, which is a practical combination in a city where the debate never really ends. The deep-dish sausage and pepperoni slice gets the most attention, with a crust that holds its crunch and a sauce that runs savory. Staff friendliness is a consistent note in the record. Pickup orders benefit from timing, since slices can sit.
The Art of Pizza is a counter-service slice shop operating at an inexpensive price point, and its reason for being is straightforward: deep-dish pizza sold by the slice, available for pickup or dine-in, without the wait of a sit-down pizzeria. That is a practical proposition in a city where deep-dish is the tourist icon and the tavern cut is the everyday local choice, and The Art of Pizza leans into the deep-dish lane without apology. The deep-dish slice with sausage and pepperoni is the thing to anchor an order here. The crust holds a noticeable crunch, which matters in deep-dish because a soggy, oil-logged base is the failure mode of lesser versions. The sauce registers on its own terms.
These are the two structural tests for any deep-dish worth eating, and the kitchen passes both on the evidence. Thin-crust slices are on the menu as well for anyone who prefers the everyday Chicago tavern-cut tradition, so the room is not a single-format operation. The staff has been called friendly and welcoming, which is worth noting for a counter-service room at this price. That register fits the neighborhood pizza-shop format. The room does have a service-timing problem on record: pickup orders have sat on the counter while customers waited in line, which means a pizza can arrive at the table cooler than it should.
For a dish where the cheese layer and the crust crunch are the payoff, temperature is not a minor issue. The kitchen can make the pizza; the front-of-house operations around pickup flow are the variable to watch. At an inexpensive price, The Art of Pizza functions as a workable deep-dish entry point, a counter-service room where the product is the point and the frills are not.
Insider tip
Order the deep-dish slice with sausage and pepperoni and eat it in the room rather than waiting on a pickup counter; temperature is everything with deep-dish, and the crust crunch suffers if the slice sits.
What to order
Deep dish sausage and pepperoni slice, Thin crust pizza, Cheese pizza
HoursMon - Thu:11:00 AM - 10:30 PMFri - Sat:11:00 AM - 11:30 PMSun:11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
Reno is a Logan Square room where the pistachio pizza with mortadella is the standout, a combination that earns its reputation among the neighborhood's regular crowd. Monday dollar-wing nights draw a different group than the weekend lunch contingent, and the quinoa salad holds its own as a standalone. The menu runs wide enough that a large table can split several directions without anyone settling.
2607 N Milwaukee Ave, Chicago, IL 60647 · (773) 697-4234
Fireside leans bar-and-grill more than pure pizza, and the room knows it. The bang bang shrimp, a full slab of ribs, and truffle fries are the items the record returns to. Bears games fill the place, and the staff manages the crowd without losing track of the regulars. The pizza is on the menu, but the room operates more like a neighborhood sports lounge with a kitchen that can handle a full dinner order.
5739 N Ravenswood Ave, Chicago, IL 60660 · (773) 561-7433
Milly's runs a pre-order model out of West Town: orders go in online in the morning, pickup later in the day. The Craigslist.org pizza, loaded with peppadew peppers, sausage, mushrooms, red onions, toy box tomatoes, and spinach ricotta, and the Updog with kumato tomatoes are the signature builds. The system requires planning, but the pies coming out of it sit at the top of the pan-pizza record in the city.
925 N Ashland Ave, Chicago, IL 60622 · (224) 656-4732
The River North Parlor location adds a large outdoor patio to the group-pizza formula the brand runs across its locations. Signature cocktails draw as much attention as the pizza, and the room handles birthday parties and Sunday group bookings when the request comes in early. The patio fills fast in warm weather; reservations cover indoor and outdoor seating both, and the record suggests the outdoor option moves first.
405 N Dearborn St, Chicago, IL 60654, United States · (312) 392-2356
Philly's Best is a cheesesteak counter, not a pizza room, and the menu is honest about what it is. The Chicken Philly and the classic with peppers and onions are the orders. The place runs late-night hours and draws a loyal crowd that returns for the cheesesteak specifically. Reviewers who have been to Philadelphia note the sandwich is its own thing, not a replica, but a solid version on its own terms.
769 W Jackson Blvd Unit 103, Chicago, IL 60661 · (312) 715-9800
Fontano's sits close enough to the Loop event corridor to catch the lunch crowd coming off conventions and festivals. The deep-dish gets positive notes from first-timers, and the menu runs subs alongside it for those who want a quicker option. The Italian sub has drawn mixed reactions on bread texture and sauce-to-bread ratio, which is worth knowing before the order goes in. Solid for a group that cannot agree on one format.
332 S Michigan Ave, Chicago, IL 60604 · (312) 663-3061
Nancy's in the West Loop runs both deep-dish and tavern-style thin crust, which makes it a practical late-night stop for the out-of-towner and the local in the same visit. The tavern-style cheese and giardiniera pizza is the right order for the Chicago-fluent table: thin, cut in squares, with giardiniera doing the work it was built for. The Caesar salad and thin crust sausage round out a short menu that covers both pizza traditions without padding the list.
1000 W Washington Blvd, Chicago, IL 60607 · (312) 733-9920
That depends on the neighborhood and the style. For tavern-cut thin crust, Paradise Park and Nancy's Pizza West Loop are strong options. For deep-dish, Pizzeria Uno and Pizzeria Due are the originals. For something more particular, Milly's Pizza In The Pan requires a pre-order but sits at the top of the pan-pizza record. Each restaurant on this list earned its place through its Insider Score, which reflects the public review record. No restaurant pays to be listed.
What is the difference between deep-dish and tavern-cut pizza in Chicago?
Deep-dish is the tourist icon, a thick, pie-like format invented in the 1940s at Pizzeria Uno. Locals eat tavern-cut far more often: cracker-thin crust, cut into squares rather than wedges, served at corner bars and neighborhood spots across the city. Both are Chicago pizza. Deep-dish takes thirty to forty-five minutes in the oven; tavern-cut is a faster, lighter meal.
Do these Chicago pizza spots take reservations?
Several do, and for the busier rooms it matters. The Parlor Pizza Bar locations across the city, Paradise Park, and the Chicago Pizza and Oven Grinder Company all see waits of an hour or more on weekend nights. Nancy's Pizza West Loop and Milly's Pizza In The Pan operate differently: Nancy's is late-night walk-in friendly, and Milly's requires an online pre-order placed the same morning. Check each spot directly for current policy.
Are these the highest-rated pizza spots in Chicago?
The list is built from Insider Scores that reflect the depth and consistency of the public review record, not a single star rating or a sponsored placement. No restaurant on this list paid to appear. The rankings reflect how each spot performs across a broad body of customer feedback, weighted for volume and recency.
The data first, then the verdict
We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →
Tony Bianchi covers the Chicago canon for Top of Chicago: deep-dish and tavern-cut pizza, the Italian beef, the Chicago dog, the Italian rooms, and South Side rib tips. A Northwest Side native who works from the public review record.