Top of Chicago

Chicago / Guides / Cheesesteaks
The Guide · Cheesesteaks

Best Cheesesteaks in Chicago (2026)

Ten restaurants across Chicago. Compare neighborhoods, price tiers and what to order, then read the full reviews.

Eleanor Brandt
By Eleanor Brandt Chief Critic · Updated September 2026 · How the score is built
Best Cheesesteaks in Chicago (2026)
THE CHICAGO DINING GUIDES 10 restaurants
Compare all 10 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Portillo's & Barnelli's ChicagoChicago$$7.2Chicago dog with everything
02 Manny's Cafeteria & DelicatessenChicago$$7.4Pastrami sandwich
03 Mr. BeefChicago$$7.8Italian beef sandwich
04 Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium ParkChicago$$5.3
05 Tony's Italian BeefChicago$6.0
06 The Original Nottoli & SonChicago$6.7
07 Tempo CafeChicago$$4.2
08 The Green Door TavernChicago$$4.8
09 Stella's DinerChicago$$5.2
10 Mr. SubmarineChicago$3.5

10 restaurants · In guide order

1 Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago Yelp

Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago

Hot Dogs · Chicago · $$
Insider Score7.2

The Chicago dog dragged through the garden is the reason to make the stop, and this location delivers it at scale. Two floors of seating and a kiosk-based ordering circle keep the operation moving for groups and solo visitors alike. The Italian beef holds its own alongside the dog, and the fries are the standard companion. Order at the counter, find a spot upstairs if the main floor is running full.

What to orderChicago dog with everythingFriesItalian beef Book a table Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

The Chicago Dog Standard, Downtown and Loud

Chicago dog with everything

Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers, and celery salt, no ketchup, not ever.

Fries

The straight-ahead side that holds up next to the dog or the beef without getting in the way.

Italian beef

Thin-sliced seasoned beef on a roll, ordered dipped and loaded with giardiniera, the way a Chicago Italian beef is supposed to go.

Portillo's is not a discovery. It is a Chicago institution, and this location operates accordingly: a two-floor room built to handle volume, with kiosk ordering at a central ring and the kind of square footage that seats a crowd without apology. The setup is fast-casual at scale, and the room runs like it knows exactly what it is. The Chicago-style hot dog is the anchor here, and it earns the reputation. Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers, and celery salt.

No shortcuts on the build, no ketchup anywhere near it. The fries come alongside and hold up as the right accompaniment. For anyone new to Chicago who has been told to try an authentic Chicago dog, this is the location most visitors end up at, and the dog itself does not let the city down. The Barnelli's side of the menu broadens the offering, running pasta salads and Italian options alongside the Portillo's hot dog and beef program. The Italian beef is on the menu, and for a city where that sandwich is civic currency, its presence here matters.

The volume this room moves means the beef stays in rotation and does not sit. That is the practical upside of a high-covers operation. The service holds even when the room is running hard. Staff manage the order flow with enough attention to catch and correct errors without friction. For a location of this size, that counts.

The price sits in the moderate range. This is not a special-occasion room. It is a Chicago-staple room, useful for anyone who needs to eat well and quickly in a city where the classics earn their place on the menu every single day.

Map showing Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago© OpenStreetMap
HoursDaily: 10:00 AM - 1:00 AM
Address100 W Ontario St
Chicago, IL, 60610
Insider tip

Order the Chicago dog with everything and do not modify the build. The kiosk ordering moves fast, but staff at the counter can fix order issues without slowing down the line.

2 Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen Yelp

Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score7.4

Open since 1942, Manny's operates on cafeteria-line service where the Reuben and the pastrami sandwich are the things to get. The matzoh ball soup holds up as a standalone. Portions run large, which partially explains the pricing. The room has the bones of a classic Jewish deli and a clientele that has been filing through for decades. Come prepared to eat.

What to orderPastrami sandwichReubenMatzoh ball soup Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

Chicago's Cafeteria Counter Since 1942

Pastrami sandwich

The pastrami sandwich is the anchor of the menu at this Chicago deli institution, drawing in those who take the classic seriously.

Reuben

The Reuben follows the deli canon here, a straightforward read on a style the kitchen has been executing since 1942.

Matzoh ball soup

Matzoh ball soup holds its place as the traditional comfort order, the kind that regulars at a serious Jewish deli come back to.

Manny's Cafeteria and Delicatessen has been feeding Chicago since 1942, and the room operates exactly the way that suggests: cafeteria-line service, trays, and portions sized for serious appetites. This is old-school Jewish deli in the city tradition, the kind of place that puts pastrami and matzoh ball soup at the center of the menu and makes no apologies for the format. The pastrami sandwich is the thing to understand here. Thinly sliced, piled, and served on rye, it carries the weight of a tradition that Chicago's Jewish deli scene once anchored and largely lost. Matzoh ball soup rounds out the picture: broth-forward, the matzoh ball substantial, the kind of dish that reads as institutional in the best sense.

The Reuben also moves through the line regularly, corned beef and sauerkraut in the cafeteria-counter format that defines how this room operates. Not every plate lands at the level the history promises, and the price point for a cafeteria-format meal registers as a real consideration for some. The room has the bones of a Chicago institution. Long-running, with a loyal crowd and a service pace that keeps things moving. The setup is counter-service tray work, not table service with a server, and the scale of the portions means no one leaves short.

Politicians, tradespeople, and locals have shared the same line here for decades, and that mix is part of what the room is. For Chicago context: Manny's operates in a city where the deli tradition thinned considerably over the decades. That makes its persistence matter, even when individual plates come in uneven.

Map showing Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen© OpenStreetMap
HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 8:00 AM - 7:30 PMSun: 8:00 AM - 3:30 PM
Address1141 S Jefferson St
Chicago, IL, 60607
Insider tip

Arrive hungry. The portions run large and the cafeteria line moves at its own pace, so knowing the order before reaching the counter helps. The pastrami and the matzoh ball soup are the reasons to make the trip.

3 Mr. Beef Yelp

Mr. Beef

Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score7.8

The Bear brought national attention to Mr. Beef, but the Italian beef and the combo sandwich were already the point. The beef comes dipped in jus, giardiniera on request, and the operation closes by four most days, so the line forms early. The sausage combo is the order for anyone who can't choose. Counter-service format, fast turnover, and a room that runs lean on space.

What to orderItalian beef sandwichCombo sandwichHot dog Call Directions
Full review & visiting detailsRead the full review & visiting details

The Italian Beef That Built The Canon

Italian beef sandwich

The house Italian beef, ordered dipped and hot with giardiniera, is the North Side standard this city measures the rest against.

Combo sandwich

Sweet peppers alongside the beef on a single roll, for anyone who wants the dip without the giardiniera heat.

Hot dog

Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden, no ketchup anywhere near it.

Mr. Beef is the Italian beef standard that Chicago keeps returning to, a counter-service sandwich shop that has operated long enough to become civic shorthand for what the city's signature sandwich is supposed to be. The room is spare, the line moves, and the operation closes at four in the afternoon because it does not need to be open longer than that. The sandwich itself is the point: thin-sliced seasoned roast beef on a roll, dipped wet in jus, finished with giardiniera or sweet peppers. That is the Chicago beef in its correct form, and Mr.

Beef does not complicate it. Order it hot and dipped and the roll absorbs enough jus to hold together without dissolving, and the giardiniera brings the heat that makes the whole thing make sense. This is not a French dip. The beef is seasoned and sliced thin and the dip is part of the construction, not an afterthought on the side. The shop drew national attention after The Bear placed it at the center of Chicago Italian beef culture on television, and out-of-towners now make it a stop.

That is fine. But the room was never built for tourism, and it does not perform for it. The counter is the counter, the hours are the hours, and the sandwich is the same sandwich it has always been. Locals who grew up in Chicagoland and somehow never tried an Italian beef have been correcting that oversight here. Moderately priced, counter service, no-reservations.

The early closing time is the one operational fact that shapes every visit. Get there well before four, because the line at the end of the day reflects what the room already knows about itself.

Map showing Mr. Beef© OpenStreetMap
HoursMon - Sat: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PMSun: Closed
Address666 N Orleans St
Chicago, IL, 60654
Insider tip

Order it dipped with hot giardiniera. The kitchen closes at four, so a mid-afternoon arrival is more reliable than pressing the closing hour.

4 Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park Yelp

Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score5.3

This is a downtown coffee and bagel stop, not a sandwich destination in the deli sense. The bagel runs light and crispy, the lattes come with latte art, and the outdoor seating makes it a reasonable pause near Millennium Park. It belongs on this list as a practical morning option for anyone in the Wabash corridor, not as a destination worth routing around.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 33 S Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60603 · (312) 877-5176
5 Tony's Italian Beef Yelp

Tony's Italian Beef

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $
Insider Score6.0

Tony's runs a no-frills Italian beef and sausage combo that lands hard. The big combo with provolone and hot peppers is the signature move, and the fries come out hot. Pricing stays low, the staff is willing to walk first-timers through the menu, and the fish sandwich shows up as a secondary option worth noting. Quick-service counter operation with a straightforward menu that does what it promises.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 7007 S Pulaski Rd, Chicago, IL 60629 · (773) 284-6787
6 The Original Nottoli & Son Yelp

The Original Nottoli & Son

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $
Insider Score6.7

A small shop off Belmont that functions as a neighborhood deli institution. The subs are the anchor, with the rotini and sausage rounding out a short menu that regulars return to repeatedly. The format is quick and counter-forward, the room is compact, and the loyal customer base has been making this a weekly stop for years. It runs at a scale that keeps things personal.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 7652 W Belmont Ave, Chicago, IL 60634 · (773) 589-1010
7 Tempo Cafe Yelp

Tempo Cafe

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score4.2

Tempo is a breakfast and brunch room, not a sandwich shop in the classic Chicago sense. The basic skillet is the standout on the menu, drip coffee and brewed tea do the work, and weekend seating moves reasonably fast for the neighborhood. Service draws consistent notice. The kitchen handles volume well on Saturday mornings, which is the main occasion this room is built for.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 6 E Chestnut St, Chicago, IL 60611 · (312) 943-4373
8 The Green Door Tavern Yelp

The Green Door Tavern

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score4.8

The Green Door Tavern is a long-running Chicago bar that has held the same block for decades. The house salad and appetizer sampler are the kitchen anchors, with draft beer as the primary draw. Its proximity to Mr. Beef makes it the natural stop for a drink after a beef run on the same block. The room carries its age honestly, which is most of its argument.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 678 N Orleans St, Chicago, IL 60654 · (312) 664-5496
9 Stella's Diner Yelp

Stella's Diner

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$
Insider Score5.2

Stella's runs the diner format straight: a bacon, egg, and cheese cheeseburger that gets repeated orders on its own, milkshakes that earn attention, and breakfast plates across a menu broad enough to require actual deliberation. The Lakeview location has operated long enough to accumulate the kind of regulars who don't need to look at the menu. Service runs above the neighborhood diner baseline.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 3042 N Broadway, Chicago, IL 60657 · (773) 472-9040
10 Mr. Submarine Yelp

Mr. Submarine

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $
Insider Score3.5

Mr. Submarine is a counter-service sub operation built for speed and low price. The Mr. Sub sandwich and cold cut combo are the standards. The format is walk-in and order, the price point stays at the low end of the scale, and the experience is straightforward for anyone who needs a sandwich quickly without much overhead. Drive-through is available, though the counter is the faster path.

Call Directions Scored from the full review record 10509 S Western Ave, Chicago, IL 60643 · (773) 238-7968
What to know before choosing a restaurant

Best Cheesesteaks in Chicago: 1. Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago · 2. Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen · 3. Mr. Beef · 4. Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park · 5. Tony's Italian Beef. Addresses, prices and what to order.

Chicago's sandwich tradition runs deep and wide, from the Italian beef counter to the Jewish deli tray to the neighborhood sub shop that's been slicing since before you were born. This guide covers the rooms where the city actually eats, organized by what the public record consistently delivers. No restaurant paid to be here.

Tours in Chicago Food tours

Frequently asked

How does the Insider Score work, and do restaurants pay to be listed?
The Insider Score aggregates public review data and weights it for consistency and volume. No restaurant pays to appear in this guide or any other on Top of Chicago. The rankings reflect the public record, not advertising relationships.
Where can I find the best cheesesteaks near me in Chicago?
Chicago's sandwich tradition leans toward the Italian beef rather than the Philly cheesesteak, so most of the rooms in this guide are deli and sandwich operations in the broader sense. Mr. Beef, Tony's Italian Beef, and the Portillo's locations are the strongest options for classic Chicago counter-service sandwiches. Use the map on this page to filter by neighborhood and Insider Score.
What is the difference between a Chicago Italian beef and a cheesesteak?
The Italian beef is thin-sliced seasoned roast beef served on an Italian roll, ordered dipped or wet in the cooking jus, and typically topped with giardiniera (spicy pickled relish) or sweet peppers. It is a Chicago original, not a variant of the Philly cheesesteak. Mr. Beef and Tony's Italian Beef are the anchors on this guide.
Are any of these spots good for groups or families?
Portillo's locations, particularly the Chicago flagship with its two-floor layout, are built for groups and families with counter-service kiosks and high seating capacity. Stella's Diner and The Green Door Tavern also handle groups reasonably well. Smaller operations like Nottoli & Son and Tony's Italian Beef are better suited for quick stops with smaller parties.
ƒ

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Eleanor Brandt
Chief Critic

Eleanor Brandt is Top of Chicago's chief critic, covering the West Loop and Fulton Market, the Michelin tier, steakhouses, and the new-American rooms. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

Five rooms, every Friday.

The new opening, the sleeper the score just flagged, and the one room worth booking this week. Free.

Get the Tip Sheet →