Chicago / Guides / Hoagies

The best hoagies in Chicago.

9 restaurants, what to order, and the details to help you choose your next meal.

Best Hoagies in Chicago (2026)
9 restaurants · 1 areaCompare the restaurants

Find your restaurant.

Showing all 9 restaurants in ranking order.

About hoagies in Chicago

Chicago's sandwich landscape runs deeper than any single icon. From the Italian beef counter at Mr. Beef to the pastrami stacks at Manny's to the neighborhood sub shops that have held their leases for decades, the city's deli-and-sandwich tradition is plainspoken, unpretentious, and serious about the product. These nine rooms represent that range.

Compare all 9 restaurantsNeighborhood · price · score · first order
In the same order as the guide. Scores are out of 10; dollar symbols show the listed price tier.
RestaurantNeighborhoodPriceScoreWhat to order
01 Portillo's & Barnelli's ChicagoChicago$$7.2Chicago dog with everything
02 Manny's Cafeteria & DelicatessenChicago$$7.4Pastrami sandwich
03 Mr. BeefChicago$$7.8Italian beef sandwich
04 Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium ParkChicago$$5.3
05 Tony's Italian BeefChicago$6.0
06 The Original Nottoli & SonChicago$6.7
07 Tempo CafeChicago$$4.2
08 The Green Door TavernChicago$$4.8
09 Mr. SubmarineChicago$3.5

9 restaurants · In guide order

01

Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago

Hot Dogs · Chicago · $$ · № 34 on the ListBack to filters

7.2Insider Score
Portillo's & Barnelli's ChicagoYelp

The Chicago Dog Standard, Downtown and Loud

The Chicago dog here arrives dragged through the garden, Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers, and celery salt. No ketchup. The room runs on kiosk ordering, spreads across two floors, and moves volume efficiently. Italian beef is the other anchor, and the fries hold up. For a first encounter with the Chicago dog canon, this location delivers the full format at a counter-service pace.

Portillo's is not a discovery. It is a Chicago institution, and this location operates accordingly: a two-floor room built to handle volume, with kiosk ordering at a central ring and the kind of square footage that seats a crowd without apology. The setup is fast-casual at scale, and the room runs like it knows exactly what it is. The Chicago-style hot dog is the anchor here, and it earns the reputation. Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers, and celery salt.

No shortcuts on the build, no ketchup anywhere near it. The fries come alongside and hold up as the right accompaniment. For anyone new to Chicago who has been told to try an authentic Chicago dog, this is the location most visitors end up at, and the dog itself does not let the city down. The Barnelli's side of the menu broadens the offering, running pasta salads and Italian options alongside the Portillo's hot dog and beef program. The Italian beef is on the menu, and for a city where that sandwich is civic currency, its presence here matters.

The volume this room moves means the beef stays in rotation and does not sit. That is the practical upside of a high-covers operation. The service holds even when the room is running hard. Staff manage the order flow with enough attention to catch and correct errors without friction. For a location of this size, that counts.

The price sits in the moderate range. This is not a special-occasion room. It is a Chicago-staple room, useful for anyone who needs to eat well and quickly in a city where the classics earn their place on the menu every single day.

Insider tip

Order the Chicago dog with everything and do not modify the build. The kiosk ordering moves fast, but staff at the counter can fix order issues without slowing down the line.

What to order

Chicago dog with everything, Fries, Italian beef

HoursDaily: 10:00 AM - 1:00 AM
Address100 W Ontario St
Chicago, IL 60610
Restaurant Reservations Call Directions
Map showing Portillo's & Barnelli's Chicago© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Chicago dog with everything

Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden with mustard, relish, onion, tomato, pickle, sport peppers, and celery salt, no ketchup, not ever.

Fries

The straight-ahead side that holds up next to the dog or the beef without getting in the way.

Italian beef

Thin-sliced seasoned beef on a roll, ordered dipped and loaded with giardiniera, the way a Chicago Italian beef is supposed to go.

02

Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$ · № 31 on the ListBack to filters

7.4Insider Score
Manny's Cafeteria & DelicatessenYelp

Cafeteria Line on Jefferson

Open since 1942, Manny's operates as a cafeteria-line deli on the South Side's edge, where the Reuben and the pastrami sandwich are the anchors. Portions run large. The matzoh ball soup belongs on the tray alongside the sandwich. Prices have climbed with the years, and the room does not pretend otherwise. What remains constant is the format: a long counter, a working-lunch pace, and the kind of institutional presence that Chicago's deli tradition depends on.

Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen on South Jefferson Street in the South Loop works cafeteria style. Diners grab a tray, slide down the line and point at what looks good behind the glass, a setup that feels chaotic and fun. The dining room is bigger than first-timers expect.

Corned beef and pastrami are hand carved and stacked on rye, and the Reuben is ranked among the top in the city. The matzo ball soup is hearty, the potato pancake is giant, and the half sandwich and soup combination is a popular way to eat. Breakfast items such as corned beef hash and challah French toast are served, along with a bakery counter.

Practical notes: portions are huge, prices run high, and the line moves quickly, with staff pushing diners along. Some diners found the corned beef dry or the soup bland on a bad visit. Parking is available but fills at lunch. Deciding the order while waiting makes the line easier.

Insider tip

Arrive hungry. The portions run large and the cafeteria line moves at its own pace, so knowing the order before reaching the counter helps. The pastrami and the matzoh ball soup are the reasons to make the trip.

What to order

Pastrami sandwich, Reuben, Matzoh ball soup

HoursMon: ClosedTue - Sat: 8:00 AM - 7:30 PMSun: 8:00 AM - 3:30 PM
Address1141 S Jefferson St
Chicago, IL 60607
Call Directions
Map showing Manny's Cafeteria & Delicatessen© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Pastrami sandwich

The pastrami sandwich is the anchor of the menu at this Chicago deli institution, drawing in those who take the classic seriously.

Reuben

The Reuben follows the deli canon here, a straightforward read on a style the kitchen has been executing since 1942.

Matzoh ball soup

Matzoh ball soup holds its place as the traditional comfort order, the kind that regulars at a serious Jewish deli come back to.

03

Mr. Beef

Sandwiches · Chicago · $$ · № 24 on the ListBack to filters

7.8Insider Score
Mr. BeefYelp

The Italian Beef That Built The Canon

Mr. Beef on Orleans is a counter-service Italian beef operation with a short menu and a firm closing time: the kitchen shuts at 4 p.m. The Italian beef sandwich is the order, sliced thin, dipped in jus, and topped with giardiniera or sweet peppers. The combo, which adds Italian sausage, is the heavier call. The room is compact and functional. Get there before the afternoon close.

Mr. Beef is the Italian beef standard that Chicago keeps returning to, a counter-service sandwich shop that has operated long enough to become civic shorthand for what the city's signature sandwich is supposed to be. The room is spare, the line moves, and the operation closes at four in the afternoon because it does not need to be open longer than that. The sandwich itself is the point: thin-sliced seasoned roast beef on a roll, dipped wet in jus, finished with giardiniera or sweet peppers. That is the Chicago beef in its correct form, and Mr.

Beef does not complicate it. Order it hot and dipped and the roll absorbs enough jus to hold together without dissolving, and the giardiniera brings the heat that makes the whole thing make sense. This is not a French dip. The beef is seasoned and sliced thin and the dip is part of the construction, not an afterthought on the side. The shop drew national attention after The Bear placed it at the center of Chicago Italian beef culture on television, and out-of-towners now make it a stop.

That is fine. But the room was never built for tourism, and it does not perform for it. The counter is the counter, the hours are the hours, and the sandwich is the same sandwich it has always been. Locals who grew up in Chicagoland and somehow never tried an Italian beef have been correcting that oversight here. Moderately priced, counter service, no-reservations.

The early closing time is the one operational fact that shapes every visit. Get there well before four, because the line at the end of the day reflects what the room already knows about itself.

Insider tip

Order it dipped with hot giardiniera. The kitchen closes at four, so a mid-afternoon arrival is more reliable than pressing the closing hour.

What to order

Italian beef sandwich, Combo sandwich, Hot dog

HoursMon - Sat: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PMSun: Closed
Address666 N Orleans St
Chicago, IL 60654
Call Directions
Map showing Mr. Beef© OpenStreetMap

More about the dishes

Italian beef sandwich

The house Italian beef, ordered dipped and hot with giardiniera, is the North Side standard this city measures the rest against.

Combo sandwich

Sweet peppers alongside the beef on a single roll, for anyone who wants the dip without the giardiniera heat.

Hot dog

Vienna Beef on a poppy-seed bun, dragged through the garden, no ketchup anywhere near it.

04

Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium Park

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$Back to filters

5.3Insider Score
Goddess and the Baker, 33 S Wabash-Millennium ParkYelp

The Wabash location sits close to Millennium Park and carries outdoor seating that draws foot traffic from the corridor. The bagel is the food anchor: light, with a crisp exterior. The latte program produces drinks with the standard specialty-coffee presentation. This is a downtown coffee-and-bagel stop rather than a destination sandwich counter. Useful for visitors moving between the park and the Loop who need a sit-down moment without committing to a full meal.

33 S Wabash Ave, Chicago, IL 60603 · (312) 877-5176

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
05

Tony's Italian Beef

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $Back to filters

6.0Insider Score
Tony's Italian BeefYelp

Tony's Italian Beef runs a short, focused menu built around the combo: Italian beef and sausage on a single roll, with hot peppers available and provolone as an option. The sandwich is the reason to stop. Fries arrive hot. Pricing sits at the lower end of the city's beef-counter range, and the staff walks first-timers through the menu without friction. A straightforward quick-bite operation that handles the Italian beef format at a reliable pace.

7007 S Pulaski Rd, Chicago, IL 60629 · (773) 284-6787

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
06

The Original Nottoli & Son

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $Back to filters

6.7Insider Score
The Original Nottoli & SonYelp

Pot Roast on Belmont Avenue

Nottoli and Son sits just off Belmont, a small shop that has built a neighborhood following over years of consistent sub work. The subs and rotini are the anchors. The room is compact, the menu focused. Repeat customers constitute the core of the operation, and the format does not change much from visit to visit. For a neighborhood deli run without ceremony, this is the kind of counter Chicago's residential corridors depend on.

The Original Nottoli & Son on West Belmont Avenue is a small Italian deli and market, with seasonings, sauces, frozen pizza and imported goods on the shelves. Diners say the shop feels like home and beats any chain sandwich shop. Homemade pickles are a surprise favorite.

The pot roast sandwich is the dish named most, tender and juicy. The Italian sub, meatball sandwich, chicken cutlet, chicken parm and Italian beef also earn praise, and macaroni salad, tiramisu and cannoli sit at the counter. Sausages and hot dishes complete the menu, and catering is offered for parties.

Practical notes: the shop gets busy fast, with lines about ten customers deep. The staff work quickly, and calling the order in avoids the wait. Signs mention short staffing at times. A few diners reported a bitter onion, a salty pot roast, or an upset stomach after a sub, so freshness is worth asking about.

HoursMon - Sun: Closed
Address7652 W Belmont Ave
Chicago, IL 60634
Call Directions
Map showing The Original Nottoli & Son© OpenStreetMap
07

Tempo Cafe

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$Back to filters

4.2Insider Score
Tempo CafeYelp

Tempo Cafe operates as an all-day diner rather than a strict sandwich counter. The basic skillet is the breakfast anchor, and drip coffee moves steadily through weekend mornings. Saturday seating can proceed without a long wait, which is its own distinction in the brunch corridor. Service here draws consistent attention in how it handles the room. The menu reads casual and straightforward, suited to a neighborhood morning rather than a destination occasion.

6 E Chestnut St, Chicago, IL 60611 · (312) 943-4373

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
08

The Green Door Tavern

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $$Back to filters

4.8Insider Score
The Green Door TavernYelp

The Green Door Tavern has been operating long enough to qualify as a River North institution. The food program leans toward salads and appetizer plates rather than a serious sandwich menu. Draft beer is the draw. The salads hold up at lunch or dinner, and the appetizer sampler works for a group grazing before or after a meal elsewhere. Its proximity to Mr. Beef makes it a natural second stop for anyone coming off an Italian beef run.

678 N Orleans St, Chicago, IL 60654 · (312) 664-5496

Call Directions Scored from the full review record
09

Mr. Submarine

Delis & Sandwiches · Chicago · $Back to filters

3.5Insider Score
Mr. SubmarineYelp

Mr. Submarine is a counter-service sandwich operation at the lower end of the price range, built around the namesake Mr. Sub and a selection of cold cut options. Drive-through service is available. The format is quick and affordable, suited to a grab-and-go run rather than a sit-down occasion. The menu stays simple. For a no-frills sandwich at a price point that reflects it, the operation covers the basics without overreaching.

10509 S Western Ave, Chicago, IL 60643 · (773) 238-7968

Call Directions Scored from the full review record

Hoagie questions, answered.

What are the best hoagies near me in Chicago?
That depends on your neighborhood. Mr. Beef on Orleans handles the Italian beef counter on the Near North Side. Manny's Cafeteria runs the pastrami and Reuben format on the South Side loop. Nottoli and Son covers the Belmont corridor. Portillo's has multiple city locations for the Chicago dog and beef sandwich. Each entry in this guide carries an Insider Score calculated from the public review record, and no restaurant pays to be listed.
Does Chicago have a distinct sandwich tradition separate from hoagies?
The Italian beef is Chicago's own: thin-sliced seasoned roast beef on a roll, ordered dipped or wet in jus, topped with giardiniera or sweet peppers. It is not a hoagie, not a French dip, and not a cheesesteak. Mr. Beef and Tony's Italian Beef both carry the format. The Chicago-style hot dog, dragged through the garden and never touched with ketchup, rounds out the city's sandwich canon alongside the Italian beef.
Are any of these spots good for a group or family outing?
Portillo's locations, particularly the Barnelli's location with its two-floor seating and kiosk ordering, handle groups efficiently. The Addison Portillo's also runs a family-friendly format with straightforward counter service. Tempo Cafe operates as an all-day diner with a casual and straightforward menu. None of these restaurants pay for placement in this guide; the Insider Score reflects the public review record only.
How does the Insider Score work, and do restaurants pay to appear in this guide?
The Insider Score is calculated from publicly available review data across sources. No restaurant pays to be listed, and no placement is sponsored. The guide exists to reflect where the city's sandwich and deli tradition actually operates, from the Italian beef counters to the neighborhood sub shops to the long-running diner formats.

The data first, then the verdict

We start with the review record, not a press release. Every room here is a real kitchen with a strong rating across a meaningful number of reviews, ranked on our 10-point Insider Score. We weight consistency over time and the rooms locals return to, not the ones tourists pass through once. The list updates as the data does. How we work →

About the writer
Eleanor Brandt
Chief Critic

Eleanor Brandt is Top of Chicago's chief critic, covering the West Loop and Fulton Market, the Michelin tier, steakhouses, and the new-American rooms. Analysis is built from the public review record, not press dinners.

A new place to try.

The Tip Sheet brings restaurant recommendations to your inbox.